Try Your New Favorite Pizza at Wise Guys of Hammondsport

Located in the scenic village of Hammondsport NY, Wise Guys of Hammondsport stands as a cornerstone of Hammondsport’s vibrant community. This beloved pizzeria embodies the essence of small-town charm. It offers a welcoming dining experience and delicious meals. For years, it has been a gathering place for locals and visitors, serving up mouth-watering pizzas and hearty subs and a generous helping of hometown hospitality.

If you’re searching for more delightful culinary adventures and attractions around this picturesque region, don’t forget to grab your free Vacation Guide. It’s your one-stop resource for all the best local attractions, events, restaurants, and more, ensuring your Finger Lakes vacation is unforgettable. Download your guide today and start planning!

A Taste of Italy in the Heart of Wine Country

Wise Guys of Hammondsport is more than just a pizzeria; it’s a testament to the fusion of Italian American cuisine with the inviting spirit of Hammondsport. This spot, located in wine country, wins hearts with its famous lasagna pizza and a menu full of hearty favorites. Every bite shows off their love for Italian food, served with a friendly smile that makes everyone feel at home. Here, every dish is more than just a meal. It’s a celebration of community spirit, where good company and great food come together in a cozy, welcoming space.

Discover the Flavors of Wise Guys of Hammondsport

A customer favorite is the lasagna pizza, a masterpiece of rich flavors and crispy crust that has become a signature dish. The menu also features favorites like pepperoni pizza, chicken wings, garlic knots, and the Buffalo Chicken Finger sub, each dish earning praise for its deliciousness and authenticity. Despite its popularity, Wise Guys never compromises on quality, ensuring every order reflects their commitment to excellence.

Located conveniently at 90 Pulteney St, Hammondsport, NY, it is a must-visit for anyone in the Finger Lakes area. Its prime location and hours cater to the needs of all guests, making it a perfect dining spot after a day of exploring.


Sun-Thurs, 11am-8pm

Fri-Sat, 11am-9pm

Explore More in Hammondsport

After savoring the flavors at Wise Guys, explore Hammondsport’s abundant charm. Glide across Keuka Lake with a boat tour, or stroll through the village to admire its historic architecture. Delve into the local wine culture at renowned vineyards or uncover maritime history at the Finger Lakes Boating Museum. Each activity in Hammondsport offers a glimpse into the rich tapestry of experiences that make this town a beloved destination.

Embrace the Comfort of Wise Guys Pizza and Hammondsport Hospitality

Wise Guys of Hammondsport is an emblem of the Finger Lakes’ warm hospitality and delicious cuisine. For those wanting the perfect blend of comfort and luxury, the Hammondsport Hotel stands as an ideal home base. 

aerial view of hotel

Our accommodations are designed for relaxation, featuring luxury linens, pillow-top mattresses, and an array of amenities, including a complimentary breakfast, indoor heated pool, and exercise facility.

Check availability to start your journey to the heart of the Finger Lakes, ensuring a delightful stay at our amenity-rich hotel. Dive into the heart of Hammondsport with a visit to Wise Guys Pizza and let the flavors of our town enrich your travel experience.